23 January 2001
Ethel Geary writes:
My father, John Geary, was a lieutenant on the Sara in the Engineering
Department, Light and Power. He told the following story relative to
this picture in his memoirs:
"Hoowey Caldwell was up above and one of the zeros or a couple of them
got after him. The photographer had a picture of a 20 millimeter shell
that was coming at him and was going to knock his arm off at the shoulder.
He took a picture of it and they showed it later. Caldwell had 200
expended shells in his cockpit, but his armored plating in there had
pretty welll saved him. He had an airelon shot off, one wheel wouldn't
come down. One of his elevators was shot up on his tail and he landed
her aboard; hedidn't catch fire. She rolled up on the deck until the
hook caught. When the hook caught she rolled up one wing, but she
stopped by then and they reached up and got him out. His wounded
rear gunner got out. They suspected that the photographer was dead,
but weren't sire until they got him out.
30 December 2000
Paul Barnett writes:
Over the holidays, I was able to get a copy of an article about the
event depicted in the picture.
If your local library has microfiche records that go back that far,
check out the July 22, 1944, issue of the Saturday Evening Post. In
that issue, there is an article entitled "We Avenge Pearl Harbor", by
Eugene Burns.
There were four people on the plane that day:
- Commander Howard Caldwell (Sparks, NV)
- Kenneth C. Bratton (Oxford, MS) in the turret
- Robert Wilder Morey (Los Angeles, CA) in the rear tunnel
- Paul T. Barnett (Corpus Christi, TX) behind the commander, taking
photographs
Caldwell was directing the attack on Rabaul Harbor from 14,000 feet. AA
batteries apparently realized this and kept shooting at him even as the
bombers started their dives. He was left alone with two escorts
(Carlton Banks Roberts of Riverside, CA, and H. M. Crockett of Salt Lake
City, UT) when they were attacked by eight Zeros at the same time.
Bratton's turret gun was knocked out, and he was seriously injured in
the knee and hip.
Barnett was shot in the head by a Zero attacking from the portside just
moments after he snapped a picture of the incoming plane.
Morey was injured by another Zero shooting from the rear, above the
stabilizer where he could not bring the tail gun to bear. But, as
Caldwell veered the plane and Morey was able to shoot down the Zero.
The plane limped back to the Saratoga. As Caldwell approached the
carrier, he had one wheel down and one up, no flaps, and no elevator
controls. As he passed over the signal officer, he held up two fingers
to signify that he had two wounded aboard (Morey had already determined
that Barnett was dead).
As he flew the length of the carrier, the engine briefly conked out and
the plane nearly settled close to the water, but the engine caught just
in time. The plane's hook caught the wire on the next time around.
The first page of the article has another picture of medical corpsmen
removing casualties from the same plane, just as Caldwell is climbing out
of the cockpit. However, it's a Xerox copy and I don't expect it to
scan very well. My father (one of Barnett's older brothers) still has
the original.
There is quite a bit more detail about the attack on Rabaul in the
article. I've tried to scan and convert it with OCR software, but ended
up with mostly gibberish. At some point in the future, I'll try it with
the original.
Paul Barnett
26 October 1996
R.W.SPIDER WEBB (with the assistance of Mr. M. Johnson) writes:
The picture you requested was wittness by R.W. "Spider" Webb ARM 2C BOMING SQD AIR
GROUP 12 USS SARATOGA November 5TH 1943. The name of the injured person shown is
Kennith BRATTON GUNNER in a plane flown by Air Group Commander CALDWELL, latter
promotted to Vice Admiral. Also in the plane was an ARM FIRST C named MORRIE,
also wounded in the plane was a SQD, Photographer sitting behind Commander CALDWELL
who was shot taking photographs of the attack on RABAUL Harbor and killed on that mission.
All aerial photographs of the attackon RABAUL Harbor that you'll ever see were taken by
Barnett. Commander Caldwell was the last plane to land because one of his landing gear was
shot away and he landed on one wheel. Also killed at REBAUL Harbor was DONALD BETTS ARM 2C
from Charles City, Iowa. ARM 2C James of Missouri was also killed. Wounded during this
attack was my brother Forest Webb (now deceased) and George Riser of Cedar Rapids, Iowa.
Missing in action in battle was Donald Betts, last seen standing on the wing of the SBD5
Dauntless that he was in that crashed in the harbor.
FB Webb and George Riser both
recovered from their wounds. Webb was transferred to the Navy Rocket range at Tower
Control, Falon Nevada and Riser returned to his Squadron.
At sundown on November 5th,
1943 fellow shipmates buried Barnett and James at Sea.
Along with the Saratoga was the
USS Princeton, they also suffered casualties from the same mission.
**Special Notice**
If anyone knows the whereabouts of Martin M. Reddy, ARM 1C Bombing 12
please let me know. During that time frame, Martin was from around 42nd and Broadway in New York City.